BADIL

  • increase font size
  • Default font size
  • decrease font size
Home Article 74 June 1997, Issue No.20
June 1997, Issue No.20
June 1997, Issue No.20

June 1997, Issue No.20 (9)

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:42

ID Cards Confiscated - Official Israeli Figures

Written by Badil-AIC

 1996             689 
1-2/1997       164 
Total             853 

Source: Interior Ministry in Ha’aretz, 17-3-1997)

This figure does not include minors who were also registered in the confiscated ID card of their parent (an average of three children per ID card).

- By May 1997, the US Consulate/East Jerusalem had collected approximately 100 cases of ID card confiscations from Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem who also hold residency/citizenship in the United States.

- The NGO Lobby launched a joint effort towards independent data collection, which - once completed - will serve as a counter-reference to official figures of ID card confiscations released by the Interior Ministry.
 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:41

NGO Lobbying and Advocacy

Written by Badil-AIC

Due to concerted efforts of local and international human rights activists, Palestinian politicians, supportive representatives of foreign governments and a few Israeli parliamentarians, Israel officially admitted - for the first time - that ID cards are being revoked from Palestinian residents of Jerusalem (see box below). Starting in 1997, mainstream Israeli media have also begun to report critically about this phenomenon (e.g. Ha’aretz 3-2 and 17-3; Jerusalem Post 15-1, 17-2; Jerusalem Report 20-2; Voice of Israel/TV Channel-1, 30-3). This, however, remains a meager success, as there are no signs that the Ministry of Interior and the Israeli government are willing to reconsider their policy.

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:37

Refugee News

Written by Badil-AIC

West Bank Refugees Decide Against Participation in PA Municipal Elections
In April 1997, the PA Ministry for Local Affairs called for a meeting with refugee activists, hoping to gain their approval for refugee participation in the upcoming municipal elections. However, refugees rejected the original proposal and presented a counter-proposal which calls for the election of camp-councils which will be the body representing refugees in their relation to the PA. Elections of camp councils will not coincide with the PA municipal elections. Following PLO approval, this decision is binding for the West Bank. In the Gaza Strip, a final decision is still pending. Since the refugee population there constitutes the majority of the population within the municipal boundaries, refugees may decide in favor of participation in the PA elections. (Source: Salah Abed Rabbo, Union of Youth Centers)

Quiet Diplomacy for Refugee Resettlement
The quiet re-settlement diplomacy of the post Oslo era has followed two approaches, one dealing with schemes of massive population transfer, the other preferring a gradual transfer of limited numbers.
The first approach includes the initial trial balloons released by Israel in 1993 and 1994 regarding a massive transfer of Palestinian refugees in Lebanon and Syria to western or southwestern Iraq. A more recent example are reported efforts by US government to convince Iraq to receive up to 500,000 Palestinian refugees from Lebanon as a trade-off for lifting the UN sanctions on Iraq.
The more recent efforts of 1996 and 1997 have shifted toward a more dispersed form of resettlement across several countries, using a quota system. The most recent piece of information is a 1997 US Congressional delegation which has taken the initiative to conduct a tour of the southern Gulf states requesting each of them to take a quota of 30,000 to 40,000 Palestinian refugees from Lebanon. These new efforts involve a transfer of Palestine refugees, gradually and in small clusters to other Arab (and possibly also Western) countries, decidedly against their collective will. The plans are initiated by forces which are not known for their sympathy to the human or national well-being of the Palestinian people.

Since re-settlement schemes are a matter of deep concern and worry among the refugee community while accurate information is difficult to access, academic research which explores these diplomatic maneuverings and brings them out into the open is needed. Such research could contribute to counter the policy of dis-information and of exclusion of Palestinian refugees from the discussion about their future fate. (Source: McGill University/Fofognet, 21-4-1997)

Canada Camp and the Irony of the Multilateral Refugee Working Group
On 18 April 1997, the following news item was published in Canada (Globe and Mail, Toronto):
“A handful of refugees stuck in Canada Camp in the Sinai region for about 15 years because of an unexpected border shift are finally home. Their reunion with relatives in the Gaza Strip is evidence that efforts to resolve the Palestinian refugee question are producing results, Canadian envoy Andrew Robinson said yesterday. Mr. Robinson, special coordinator for the Middle East peace process, went to the Gaza Strip on Wednesday to greet eight heads of household who returned with their families. ‘This is a concrete expression of the benefits of the peace process for Palestinian refugee families,’ Mr. Robinson said before returning to Canada.”

A response by Elia Zureik, Professor of Sociology, Queen’s University, Kingston (Canada) was published in the same newspaper on 21 April 1997:

“The Refugee Working Group of the Middle East peace process has been meeting for five years to deal with the thorny issue of Palestinian refugees. Mr. Andrew Robinson, the current Canadian coordinator of the Refugee Working Group, was personally at hand to welcome the return of eight Palestinian refugee households from the Sinai desert to the Gaza Strip. He later commented that this return was ‘a concrete expression of the benefits of the peace process’. For someone who has been a member of the Palestinian delegation to this Working Group since its inception, this comment sounds comical had it not been for the sad reality it hides, namely that according to the United Nations there are more than four million individual refugees, stranded and waiting to go home. At this rate it is going to take two, three or more centuries to return the rest. I trust that Mr. Robinson will keep the faith and will be there to welcome the remaining refugees upon their return.” (McGill University/Fofognet, 21-4-1997 and 19-5-1997)
 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:36

Palestine Refugees

Written by Badil-AIC

50 Years Under the Tent”
Campaign for the Defense of Palestinian Refugee Rights

Right of Return Re-assessed

Report from a series of workshops organized by the NGO Campaign for the Defense of Refugee Rights (Alternative Information Center, Jerusalem Open University/Refugee Studies Center, Union of Youth Activities Centers/West Bank)

The Role of the Palestinian Legislative Council/Refugee Subcommittee in Protecting Refugees’ Right of Return
(Workshop 1, Jerusalem Open University/Refugee Studies Center, Ramallah; 15-5-1997)

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:35

Testimony On ID Card Confiscations

Written by Badil-AIC

to the UN Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices Affecting the Human Rights of the Palestinian People and Other Arabs in the Occupied Territories (AIC/Project for Palestinian Residency & Refugee Rights, Cairo, 31 May 1997):

AIC staff presented case files and background information to the Committee composed of UN ambassadors of several African and Asian countries and the Human Rights Officer of the UN High Commissioner on Human Rights. Egyptian press and TV reported extensively about the testimony.
 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:35

US Human Rights Activists Address PLO Ambassador to the UN

Written by Badil-AIC

Dear Ambassador al-Qidwa
I am writing to urge your office to join us as we advocate for the residency rights of Palestinians in Jerusalem. We feel the issue needs to be a priority for the PLO and the Palestinian Authority, given the serious developments in recent months. While Palestinian family reunification permits in Jerusalem have always faced hurdles, the cancellation of Jerusalem identity cards due to “center of life” requirements and recent revelations that 10,000 applications have yet to receive even initial review by the Israeli Interior Ministry compels us to speak out strongly against these human rights violations.

I look forward to your cooperation and leadership in defending Palestinian rights in Jerusalem in light of continuing Israeli government abuses.

Sincerely,

Member of the Campaign for Palestinian Residency Rights in Jerusalem, USA.

Note: This post card petition was initiated by the AFSC Chicago in March 1997. Numerous copies of a similar letter have been addressed to Palestine President Yasser Arafat. As of June 1997, neither the Presidential Office nor Ambassador al-Qidwa had sent their response.

 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:34

Speaking Tour in the United States

Written by Badil-AIC

Based on an initiative by the AFSC, the two renowned human rights lawyers Lea Tsemel and Usama Halabi toured the United States from 28 April to 5 May 1997 in order to raise the issue of ID card confiscations in Jerusalem to the US public and policy makers. The program included meetings with US Congressmen and Senators (e.g. Lugar, Feinstein, Wellstone, Moynihan), and with the State Department; a briefing to the UN Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People and a meeting with Nasser al-Qidwa, the PLO ambassador to the UN; numerous public lectures and discussions with human rights activists, Arab-American community activists, and university students and staff in Chicago, Washington, Portland, Cleveland and Philadelphia; and several TV and radio interviews. In general, the US audience, who had been ill informed on the issue, were very receptive and eager to follow up.
One day after the lawyers’ departure, the Washington Post featured two sympathetic articles detailing the Israeli practice of denying Palestinian Jerusalemites their ID cards (“Israel Chips Away East Jerusalem ID Cards” and “You Have ... Ceased to Be a Resident”, Washington Post, 5-5-1997), and the US State Department also made a public statement in its Daily Press briefing, confirming that discussions about Palestinian residency rights with the Israeli government had taken place. The State Department official implied that Israel may be “altering” their practices (see opening article in this ARTICLE 74). The reportedly most disappointing experiences were the confrontation with the fact that the Arab American public is among the least informed about the actual situation in Jerusalem on the one hand, and the response of PLO ambassador to the UN, Nasser al Qidwa on the other. Mr. Qidwa suggested that Palestinian Jerusalemites who are no longer permitted to live in Jerusalem, could just move to Nablus or Ramallah, i.e. a response which shows that an earlier post card petition addressing Mr. Qidwa was more than justified (see below).
 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:33

Independent Survey

Written by Badil-AIC

On 15 May 1997, the Lobby for Palestinian Women’s Rights in Jerusalem in cooperation with the Follow-up Committee on Human Rights Violations in Jerusalem launched an independent survey on ID card confiscations in Jerusalem. Jerusalemites were called in press and TV announcements to fill a standard questionnaire available in various NGO offices in and around Jerusalem, as well as in the offices of the PA Legislative Council in al Ram. The initiative received much support by the local Palestinian press: al-Quds newspaper published the questionnaire free of charge, and NGOs are planning to approach the Jordanian press for similar cooperation. Moreover, the questionnaire has been disseminated via various NGO newsletters and magazines and can be found on internet (http://aic.netgate.net)
NGOs aim - by means of this survey - to obtain an independent estimate of the scope of ID card confiscations in the city, and hope to expand the outreach of their legal counseling services.

 

ID Card Confiscations - Official and Independent Figures 

Official Israeli figures: 
1996                               689*  
1-5/1997                         787**  
Total                            1,476 

Source: *Interior Ministry in Ha'aretz, 17-3-1997; **Interior Ministry in al-Quds, 5-5-1997

Independent Figures (NGO Survey)

Number of cases registered by 17 June 1997: 137

These figures do not include minors who were also registered in the confiscated ID card of their parent (an average of three children per ID card).

 

Mercredi, 09 Septembre 2009 14:32

ID Card Confiscation Update

Written by Badil-AIC

In response to pressure from the United States, especially prior to the latest visit of US special envoy Dennis Ross in early May 1997, Prime Minister Netanyahu held a series of talks aimed at finding ways for easing up on ID card confiscation in Jerusalem. However, while the Netanyahu government may be in the defensive and thus ready for “good will gestures”, the Interior Ministry - much less concerned about Israel’s diplomatic fame - announced that it planned to continue confiscating ID cards of Arabs leaving the city as permitted by the Israeli law.